Implantable defibrillators devices that
detect and correct an abnormal heart rhythm are associated with a
high risk of long-term complications, a new study suggests.
- High rate of complications
"An implantable
cardioverter-defibrillator is a highly effective treatment option to reduce the
risk of sudden cardiac death," said lead researcher Dr Isuru Ranasinghe, a
senior cardiologist at the University of Adelaide in South Australia.
"However, there is a substantial and
persistent risk of device-related complications and re-operations in the years
after implantation."
These complications include device malfunction,
infection and inflammation.
Ranasinghe said the rate of complications
is higher than previously reported. "The continued occurrence of
complications long after the initial implantation indicates the need for
vigilance and ongoing surveillance of ICD-related complications," he said.
But one cardiologist not involved with the
study called the risk of complications "modest" and added that the
benefits offered by the devices outweigh the risks.
ICDs are battery-powered devices placed in
a "pocket" under the skin to keep track of a patient's heart rate. When
an abnormal or chaotic heart beat occurs, the device is meant to shock the
heart and restore a normal heart rhythm.
- Simpler may be better
For the study, researchers analysed the
performance of three types of implantable defibrillators – single-chamber,
dual-chamber and cardiac resynchronization therapy devices (CRT-D). The
investigators found the chances for trouble were greater with more complex
devices, especially CRT-D devices.
Compared with simpler devices, CRT-D
devices have a 38 percent higher rate of complications, and quadruple the risk
for procedures such as battery replacement and upgrades, the researchers
determined.
"This is important because choosing a
simpler device at the start may help patients by reducing complications and
delaying the need to replace the device," Ranasinghe said.
The ICD lifespan is typically up to seven
years, depending on when the battery needs replacing, Ranasinghe said.
"More complex devices are more active,
and their battery needs replacing earlier, compared with simpler devices,"
he explained.
"There is considerable debate as to
the added benefit of more complex devices compared with simpler, single-chamber
ICDs," Ranasinghe said. "Where possible, using a simpler device may
reduce the risk of ICD-related harm."
One expert believes the risk of
complications is "modest", not significant enough to change current
practice.
"Clinical trials have shown that
implantable defibrillators prolong life, with benefits that outweigh potential
risks," said Dr Gregg Fonarow, a professor of cardiology at the University of California, Los Angeles.
- Higher risk for women and blacks
These new findings "further reinforce
current guideline recommendations for the use of these implanted devices in
patients at risk for sudden death who are eligible and without
contraindications," Fonarow said.
For the study, Ranasinghe and colleagues
collected data on more than 114,000 men and women aged 65 and older who
received an ICD between 2006 and 2010. The patients were followed for three
years.
The researchers found that women and blacks
had a somewhat higher risk of complications compared to men and whites. In
addition, younger seniors – those 65 to 69 at implantation – had more
complications than people 85 and older, Ranasinghe said.
Why women and blacks are more susceptible
to complications isn't clear and requires further investigation, he said.
"Still, our findings can be used by
physicians and patients to make an informed choice when weighing up the risks
and benefits of an ICD," Ranasinghe added.
Visit the Supply Doctor website today to order all your medical equipment and supplies. Not only is it convenient and affordable, but you can do it from the comfort of your own home!
No comments:
Post a Comment